We come to another of the book’s 74 chapters that by itself is worth the
price of purchase. Before dealing with the chapter in a somewhat unusual manner
I would like to recollect several experiences, both mine and others.
One of my closest and dearest friends was the late Kenneth Connolly, a
son of the notable Peter Connolly. I remember talking to Ken about his dad, so
wonderfully used by God with Jock Troup in the Fisherman’s Revival in England
in 1921. Later moving to the USA, Peter Connolly taught at a well-known Bible
college in the Bible belt and was a favorite of students. One man mentored by
Peter Connolly told me that “once you heard the man pray you were his former
life.” Yet Peter Connolly was fired for teaching Calvinism, with the
circumstances of his termination being very strange. Though only one of several
men who served that Bible college as Calvinists (one being a man who later was
my pastor), Peter Connolly was terminated because he was the most prominent.
When approached by the college administration with the insistence that he stop
using Calvinistic terminology while continuing to teach the same doctrinal
truths, Connolly declined and was terminated. It has been widely believed that
his termination was the result of protests by supporting pastors who were virulently
opposed more to the word Calvinism than to the doctrines that lay back of the
word.
A second anecdote occurred when a younger than I pastor in California related
to me of his sad estrangement from his pastor, under whose ministry he came to
Christ and was mentored. Then the young man became curious about the doctrine
of salvation and began asking questions to his beloved pastor. Curiously, his
pastor was unwilling to discuss what the Bible teaches about the doctrine of
salvation. As the younger preacher began to press his pastor with questions about
the issues a cooling of the relationship became more and more noticeable until
finally the young man’s pastor ended the relationship. Interestingly, the young
man’s opinion is that the relationship ended as a direct result of his interest
in learning from his pastor what the Bible teaches about the salvation of a
sinner.
My own experience was somewhat along this line. As a new Christian I
asked my pastor several questions about the word election. My pastor responded
by informing me that election was not an issue that should be discussed with
new Christians. I found his answer unpersuasive, because of the words used by
the Apostle Paul when writing to the new Christians in Thessalonica: “Knowing,
brethren beloved, your election of God.”
A final comment about the half-century effort by the late John R. Rice
to convince his Sword of the Lord readers that the Calvinism of C. H.
Spurgeon, George Whitefield, and Jonathan Edwards (frequently referred to as
five-point Calvinism) was Hyper-Calvinism. I accepted Rice’s assertion for many
years, until I was made aware of Spurgeon’s concerted efforts against
Hyper-Calvinism in London at the beginning of his ministry.
How could a five-point Calvinist be a Hyper-Calvinist if a five-point Calvinist
strongly and publicly (and successful) opposed Hyper-Calvinism? He could not
be. Rice’s insistence that five-point Calvinism is Hyper-Calvinism is
erroneous. Agreeing on terminology is crucial.
I have been a Christian long enough to know that believers in Christ
will not always agree with each other. I sometimes jokingly remark that at
times I do not agree with myself. I would suggest that two prominent reasons
for disagreement are, #1 studying God’s Word using differing hermeneutical
approaches, and #2 God’s sovereign illumination of different believers in
different ways and to different degrees. Yet so many are frightened to discuss doctrines
with those with whom they disagree, frequently supposing that all differences
are the result of personal sin. Although that can be the case, I am persuaded
that it is not necessarily the case.
In this chapter the author deals with 22 objections to the doctrine of
election. Regardless of the position one holds I think it is imperative that
these objections be dealt with, discussed, and carefully examined.
Objection 1: “Calvinism kills evangelism.” Three
paragraphs. My response to this objection is George Whitefield, Jonathan
Edwards, William Carey, Adoniram Judson, Hudson Taylor, and my Nepalese Baptist
church planting friend, Samuel Rai, who has established more than 160 Baptist
churches over the last 30 years while embracing the Second London Baptist Confession
of Faith.
Objection 2: “Whosoever will may come.” Four
paragraphs. The author objects to the notion that there is a contradiction
between election and the free offer. Additionally, he speaks to the errors of Hyper-Calvinism
and Arminianism.
Objection 3: “Calvinism portrays God turning away
sinners because they are not elect.” Two
paragraphs. The author writes, “Christ has never turned away any repentant sinner
nor ever will – nor do Calvinists even hint that He will.”
Objection 4: “If election were true, then the
non-elect would never have a chance to be saved.” Two paragraphs explaining
why this is an ill-founded objection.
Objection 5: “God votes for you. Satan votes against
you. How you vote decides the election.” Two paragraphs.
Objection 6: “God is no respecter of persons.” Three
paragraphs. My opinion is that this objection betrays a fundamental
misunderstanding of the difference between God being impartial and God being no
respecter of persons.
Objection 7: “A similar objection says that ‘Predestination
is privilege, and all privilege is wrong.’” Two paragraphs. Really? Abraham
was privileged. Was that wrong?
Objection 8: “If I am elected, I can live in sin,
for God will save me anyway.” One paragraph. Believed and stated by no
Calvinist ever.
Objection 9: “To deny faith a place in election is
like denying faith a place in justification, which is heresy.” Two
paragraphs. The author deals with the five points of Arminianism.
Objection 10: “If election were true, then I
would be saved if I am elect, whether I believe it or not, or I would be damned
if not elect, whether I believe or not.” One paragraph.
Objection 11: “Election is not practical.”
Two sentences.
Objection 12: “Calvin taught election and
burned Servetus at the stake; Augustine taught election and believed in several
Catholic heresies such as baptismal regeneration.” The author does not
state, so I will, that Calvin was never in his lifetime at the helm of Geneva’s
government. The author points out that Calvin and Augustine also taught the
Trinity and infallibility. Are we, therefore, to deny those doctrines because
they were taught by those two men?
Objection 13: “Election is too speculative.”
Two sentences.
Objection 14: “Most Christians do not believe
in election. My church does not.” Three sentences.
Objection 15: “It sounds like leftover Roman
Catholicism.” The author deals with this objection with four sentences. My
response is that if you advance this objection you know nothing of contemporary
Roman Catholicism.
Objection 16: “It sounds too complicated.”
One sentence. “What is complicated about these three words: ‘He choose us’ (Ephesians
1:4)?”
Objection 17: “I heard a well-known preacher
warn against election.” Two sentences.
Objection 18: “I have read all the way through
the Bible, and I cannot find the doctrine of election anywhere in it.” One
paragraph. The author begins the paragraph, “Keep reading.”
Objection 19: “I do not believe in election
even if it is in the Bible.” Four paragraphs. This is the statement of a
lost person.
Objection 20: “God loves everybody equally,
therefore a Reformed doctrine of election is not true.” Six paragraphs. God
does not love everybody equally!
Objection 21: “Calvinist election looks like
hospital triage. He could not save everyone, so He chose which ones had the
best likelihood of being saved.” One paragraph, containing six sentences.
In my opinion, this objection is blasphemous, severely limiting God’s power.
Objection 22: “It is not fair!” Ten
paragraphs. My response to this objection is based on my experience of growing
up in a different culture, where the concept of fair play is foreign. I assert
that there is no such thing as fair, except in the minds of English-speaking
westerners. The author’s response differs from mine.
Conclusion: Two paragraphs, which includes a quote from
Jonathan Edwards: “It becomes worms of the dust therefore to subject their
understandings to God’s and to own that God knows more than they, and not to
find fault with what he did from eternal ages in his infinitely wise and holy
counsel’s.
Iain
H. Murray, Spurgeon v. Hyper-Calvinism: The Battle for Gospel Preaching
(Carlisle, PA: The Banner of Truth Trust, 1995)